The first move
One rude message at 6 pm. Why does it get my whole evening?
A colleague sends eleven words, none of them "please". You read them in the lift lobby with your bag on your shoulder. That was half an hour ago. The bag is still on your shoulder.
The written message is one of humanity's great inventions. It lets a person be rude to you from another building, at a time of their choosing, and then go and have a pleasant dinner. Before this, they had to come and do it in person, which at least used up some of their evening too.
What is curious is what happens next. The same message lands on two phones. One owner reads it, types "Noted", and starts on the onions. The other reads it nine times, checks whether "Regards" has always been that cold, and is unavailable to their household until further notice.
The message, continued
-
6:01 pm
"As discussed, this was due Friday." It was not discussed. You go looking for the email in which it was not discussed.
-
At dinner
The family is discussing a cousin's wedding menu. You are on Reply, Version 7, the one that opens "With respect".
-
10:30 pm
You find you have been brushing the same four teeth for some time. The other twenty-eight were not copied on the message.
-
Next morning
The sender greets you warmly and asks about your evening. They have no memory of the message. You have a memory of little else.
The science of one step back
There is no branch of science called Not Taking Things Personally, which is a pity, because the conferences would be very relaxed. What researchers do study is the move underneath it. They call it self-distancing: looking at a bad moment from one step back, as if it had happened to someone you know well and are fairly fond of.
The step can be small. You describe the moment using your own name where you would say "I", or you picture how it looks from next year. A neighbouring line of research looks at people who make a habit of rethinking what a thing means, and finds they tend to be doing rather well.
-
One step back
A large review of self-distancing research links stepping back from a hard moment with less distress and less replaying of it.
Some evidence -
Rethinkers do better
In questionnaire studies, people who made a habit of rethinking what a situation meant reported more positive emotion and better well-being. A link, not a cause.
Some evidence -
A smile, maybe
In one small lab study, people who held a smile through a stressful task had somewhat faster heart-rate recovery. It has not been widely repeated. Do not grin at your inbox on this basis.
Early evidence
Advice, unrequested
All of it from people who have never met your colleague.
-
A kind coworker
"Don't take it personally."
The catch It was addressed to you, by name, with your manager in copy. It is hard to see who else was meant to take it.
-
Career forums
Reply at once, firmly, and set a boundary.
The catch A reply written at 6:05 is a document you get to reread at 2 am. Drafts are free. Send is permanent.
-
Psychologists
Step back before you answer. Tell yourself what happened as if it happened to someone else.
The catch This is the advice with studies behind it. It is also suspiciously cheap.
-
Doctors
If one message can regularly take your sleep or several days from you, talk it through with a professional.
The catch A web page can hand you an experiment. It can't sit across a desk from you.
Materials science
Three things a hit can do
When anything strikes a surface, a wave, a hammer, a sharp sentence, an engineer asks one question first: where did the energy go? There are three answers. Some of it is reflected and goes back the way it came. Some is absorbed and stays inside. Some is transmitted and comes straight out the other side, usually at whoever is standing there.
Materials split the load differently, and so do people. Granite sends most of it back; you can shout at a granite worktop all afternoon and it will be exactly as helpful as before. Chalk takes it in and keeps a mark. Both have a trade. Chalk is what you want for writing things down, and nobody has ever felt understood by a worktop. But at 6 pm it is worth knowing which of the two is holding the phone.
Is this your evening? Tick what fits
Tick any that fit.
Five quick picks to find your first move: bounce off, hold in or let out.
Find out in five picksVedic astrology
What the old texts give to the Sun
The reply-all button is recent. The classical Jyotish texts are not, yet they had already made a place for this problem. They give the self to the Sun. The Phaladeepika lists patience among the things the Sun stands for, next to light and the soul, and gives the Sun an address: open places, with light in them. The first house, or rising sign, gets a person's vigour, weakness and innate nature.
Stated baldly, the old idea is that a well-placed Sun or first house means a self with thick walls and good lighting, where a sharp remark stops at the surface. Reading the verses as a portrait of the person who types "Noted" is our doing; the authors had other things on their minds. Nobody has tested it. The study on this site is the test.
The places governed by the Sun are ... open spaces, places where there is light, regions where there is no water and the Eastern quarter.Phaladeepika, 2.15
The Sun's side of you: see if these fit
Tick any that fit.
Now look at your chart
Open your Vedic chart (sidereal; most free apps default to Lahiri). The texts tie each of these to a self that holds its shape:
Found none? By the old idea, that fits an evening lost to eleven words. Found three and still lost it? Then the idea is in trouble, and we would like to hear.
Our reading of the verses is unchecked so far. Nothing in a chart tells you how tomorrow's messages are going to land.
Your 15-day experiment
Ten minutes of sky
Meet the day before the inbox does.
- PsychologyDescribing a sting from one step back, using your own name, is linked with less distress and less replaying.
- MechanicsA surface reflects what it meets while it is firm. So you set the surface first, before the day's first load arrives.
- Karma alignmentDaylight and open places belong to the Sun in the texts, and the Sun stands for the self.
Each day
- Each morning, before opening any message, stand somewhere open with daylight: a terrace, a balcony, the street. Ten minutes. Phone in your pocket.
- For the last two minutes, take yesterday's sharpest moment and report it silently using your own name. "Nova got a curt message at six. Nova read it nine times."
- Then go in and open the inbox.
Each evening, write one line for each
- Did a sharp message or remark land today? How long did it stay: minutes, hours, or still here?
- Did you open any message before the ten minutes were up?
- Did the own-name report feel silly, useful, or both?
Day 1 of 15
Under fifteen minutes a day. Free. Nothing rides on it.
- Day 5 Count the evenings lost so far. Compare with the five days before you began, as best you remember.
- Day 10 Look at how long each sting stayed. Shorter, or the same length but quieter?
- Day 15 Reread day 1. Would that message cost you the same evening now? Tell us.
Quick answers
How do I stop taking things personally at work?
Research does not study taking things personally as such. The closest tested idea is self-distancing: describing the event from a step back, for example using your own name. Studies link it with less distress and less replaying.
Why does one rude message ruin my whole evening?
The message ends but the thinking about it continues. Research on self-distancing links stepping back from a hard moment with less distress and less replaying of it.
Is not taking things personally the same as not caring?
No. Stepping back changes where you view the event from, not whether it matters. You can still answer the message. If messages regularly cost you sleep, speak to a professional.